Here are my Saints draft grades
Marshon Lattimore CB Ohio State. Full disclosure. I wanted an explosive offensive player here. I've stated my reasons why ad nauseam. To those of you who think I'm crazy, we just disagree. Having stated that, this could be an A+ pic if he can stay healthy. I have two reservations about Lattimore. 1. The dude is high maintenance. Because of his chronic hamstring injuries, he requires a special diet, training regime and practice routine. It's said he may require extra care from an NFL medical staff just to keep him healthy. Uhhh, that's before he even takes the field. BTW, when you see "chronic" in a diagnosis, That means it doesn't go away. Big. Red. Flag. 2. Scouts reported that he played exclusively right side CB at OSU. On the boundary. If true, this would indicate that coaches were trying to "hide" him. What I love about Lattimore, and why I think Saints coaches fell in love with him, is his elite play-making skills. He can catch the ball, he can break on the ball, he's fast enough to keep pace with any receiver or cover ground to get to the ball in flight. Again, he makes the catch. Too often Saints DBs have been unable to finish. Offenses had too many chances at redemption. The Saints D ain't got no time for that. Considering his elite ball skills, Lattimore can be a quality NFL starter. Maybe
even a pro bowler. But his high maintenance and history of hammies, could make this another lost Saints #1 draft choice. "Scouting" services had him rated as high as the #4 prospect in the draft. Please. That's Deion Sanders territory. Ten teams don't pass on a talent like that. Lattimore is no Deion Sanders. But then again, who is. Big risk/reward. B-
Ryan Ramczyc OT. Wisconsin. 6'6" 310 former D3 player who transferred to Wisconsin and turned into an All Big Ten and All American player. He is an agile lineman with an attitude. I like that in a OL. LSU fans will remember how he dominated Arden Key, Lewis Neal and company in the season opener. As a tackle he checks all the boxes. Quick to the second level. Long arms for leverage. Exhibits great technique and toughness(Played through a hip injury). Athletic. Excels in both run and pass blocking. Interestingly, he played left tackle for the Badgers. Maybe the Saints have become exhausted by Terron Armstead's constant string of hangnail injuries. He's become unreliable.
But, Ramczyc has an injury concern of his own. He had hip surgery January 5th. Probably why he fell to 32. Dominant LT's usually don't make it out of the top ten. He may not be ready for OTA's or slight chance, the season. The Saints said they would've loved an edge rusher at 32 but value wasn't there. To be clear, yes there were edge rushers available at 11 and 32. Just not good enough for the Saints, they say. We'll see how this plays out. Hip notwithstanding, once he's cleared to play, he'll be a legit NFL starting tackle. For a long long time. Added bonus, the Saints own his 5th year option. Now that's value. I know they needed that edge guy but. B+
Marcus Williams S Utah 6'1" 202 First team All-Conference in 2015 and academic all conference (4.0 GPA). A nice sized free safety with with speed and range. Finds the ball quickly and moves fluidly to trace it in flight. He is a legit centerfielder with good football instincts. But his best feature is that he is a play-maker. That's two defensive play-makers in the first three picks. Ya think the Saints saw that as a need? Will aide Lattimore with over the top coverage. The knock on Williams is his slender build which can be corrected in the weight room. He also tends to absorb hits instead of taking it to ball carriers. Lastly, and most critical, at times he followed QBs eyes and can be manipulated. QBs love playing safeties they can easily manipulate. This, too, can be corrected. Athletic, speed, range and playmaking skills. Correctable flaws. Good value in 2nd round. B+
Alvin Kamara RB Tennessee 5'11" 212. Kamara was in everybody's top five at RB. This team has not been the same since they let Darren Sproles get away. They haven't made the playoffs since. Three straight 7-9 seasons. The Saints need that element back in their offense. The two running backs in this draft closest to Sproles were Christian McCaffrey and Alvin Kamara. The Saints didn't get a chance to select McCaffrey so they made sure they got in position to select Kamara. This returns the X factor to the offense. This to me is a homerun pick. First round talent in the third round. Kamara has size, speed, quickness, agility. He's a major threat in the passing game. He has enough size to run between the tackles. He has good balance and vision. Looking at Kamara's tape, he's a Sproles/Pierre Thomas hybrid. He has the slippery running style of Thomas and the speedy quickness and pass catching ability of Sproles. On the negative side. Kamara came at a high price. Next year's #2. I don't mind the 7 because, well, Saints, draft. But the second round has been pretty good to the Saints(See Mike Thomas). Kamara also has a lighter resume than you may want. But 6.5 yards per carry. I'm in. Grade: A
Alex Anzalone LB UF 6'3" 240. For all the anti-LSU conspiracies, this one is the clincher. Would the Saints have taken Leonard Fournette if they had the chance? We'll never know. They say they would've taken Duke Riley in the third round but the Falcons got there first. Ok, you passed on him earlier in the third round but hey, benefit of the doubt, right? But selecting Anzalone with Kendall Beckwith sitting right there in your backyard ends all doubt. Anzalone's resume reads like a hospital chart. Broken arm. Separated shoulder. Dislocated shoulder. Every season lost to injury. And it's not like shoulder separations never return. They're like ankle sprains. One leads to another which leads to another. The ligaments surrounding the joint stretch and become more and more lax. They start separating during everyday movements like reaching for a glass, muchless straining for leverage, tackling and all other football moves. There's only two reasons I can think why they choose Anzalone:
1. He looks like Clay Matthews
2. He didn't play at LSU. It certainly can't be what they saw on the field. Maybe Beckwith's ACL injury could be why the Saints passed(that would be a first), but that didn't matter to Tampa Bay, who gladly snapped him up the very next pic. Knowing this crew, Saints war room probably broke out into laughter. "Silly Tampa Bay, choosing another LSU LB! Ha ha ha!" Yeah ok. Anzalone is athletic and was productive in limited playing time. C-
Trey Hendrickson DE FAU. 6'5" 265. This and Kamara are my two favorites picks. Hendrickson is projected by many to add depth to the Saints DL. I'm here to tell you, he could start. He is pure energy and intensity. He doesn't tackle ball carriers, he pulverizes them. Imagine Kenny Vaccaro's motor at 270lbs with a 4.65 40 time. I seem to remember something about that in physics. What was it? Oh yeah, mass x velocity plus intensity equals injured QB. Grade A
Al-Quadin Muhammad DE/OLB The U 6'3" 250.You may know Muhammad by his alias,Suspension-And Dismissal. This is what his college career is known for. Is he any good? Who cares. He's probably won't make it through an entire season to find out. This pick smells like Tevon Rooks pick. Only one round higher. Rooks. You may remember, is the OT selected a few years back in round seven who barely survived OTA's. What makes the Muhammad pick most frustrating is all the players still on the board from great programs and didn't get in trouble. How about Jeremy Clark 6'3" 220 CB from Michigan? Or Bucky Hodges a 6'6" 260 TE with 4.57 speed from VaTech? Or if you wanted DL, you had Jeremy Ledbetter DE Arkansas and D.J. Jones DT from right up the street at Ole Miss.
my point is sure round six is where you can take a chance, go out on a limb. But man, make sure that limb doesn't snap. Grade F-
So the Saints potentially helped their secondary, got a legit OT, replaced Darren Sproles and found a hidden gem at DE. On the other hand, they again ignored LSU and wasted their lone pick of the final four rounds. That's four of six on the good side. Potentally. Remember the immortal words of Jim Mora about potential?
Overall grade: B
